The Southside Strangler, and the test that caught him
In the fall of 1987 a killer moved through Southside Richmond and nobody could find him. A paternity lab in New York did. He became the first man in America sentenced to death on DNA evidence.
In September 1987 a man got out of prison early and went to a halfway house on the Southside of Richmond. Two weeks later a woman was found dead in her apartment in Westover Hills.
By Thanksgiving there were three women dead in the Richmond area and one more in Arlington. All of them were raped and strangled in their own homes, at night, by somebody who came in through a window and left almost nothing behind. The papers started calling him the Southside Strangler after the second one, and for a few months a lot of people on that side of the river slept with the lights on.
I learned about it as an adult, watching Forensic Files. It wasn’t a subject adults talked about with kids, and it wasn’t something Richmonders wanted to keep fresh in their minds.
The detective who remembered a kid named Timmy
Richmond police had almost nothing. What broke it open came from Arlington.
An Arlington detective named Joe Horgas had a 1984 murder in his files that looked a lot like the new one in his county. When a teletype came through from Richmond about their cases, he called a Richmond detective named Glenn Williams and they compared notes. The killings matched. Then Horgas remembered something from years earlier: a kid in that Arlington neighborhood named Timmy who was always in trouble.
He ran it down through parole records and a driver’s license. Timothy Spencer had grown up a mile from the Arlington victim, had done time for burglaries in the Richmond area, and had been released to that Southside halfway house two weeks before the first Richmond killing. He had been home in Arlington with his mother for Thanksgiving.
Horgas arrested him at the halfway house in Richmond on January 20, 1988.
The paternity lab
Fingerprints didn’t help. There were no witnesses. What there was, from almost every scene, was semen.
In 1987 nobody in American law enforcement had a working DNA lab. So Richmond police mailed their samples to a private company in New York called Lifecodes, which mostly did paternity tests. Horgas drove the Arlington samples there too. They all came back as the same man, and the man was Spencer.
The question was whether a jury would ever get to hear it. Nobody in the country had sent a man to death row on DNA. An Arlington judge held a special hearing just to decide whether the science was real enough to use, and decided it was. In July 1988 Spencer was convicted of the Arlington murder and sentenced to death, the first death sentence in America that rested on DNA. In the first Richmond trial that fall, the prosecution told the jury the odds of the match being anybody else were one in 705 million.
He was convicted for all four 1987 murders and got four death sentences. Virginia executed him in the electric chair at Greensville Correctional Center on April 27, 1994. He didn’t make a final statement.
The man who did his time
Here’s the part that should bother everybody.
That 1984 murder in Arlington, the one Horgas kept thinking about, already had somebody in prison for it. His name is David Vasquez. He was a janitor at a McDonald’s with an IQ under 70. Detectives questioned him for hours and told him his fingerprints were in the house, which wasn’t true. He confessed, took it back, and then pleaded guilty while saying he didn’t do it, because a plea was safer than a capital murder trial. He got 35 years.
DNA couldn’t clear him directly, because there wasn’t enough evidence left from 1984 to test. But once Spencer was tied to the 1987 killings, the FBI concluded Spencer most likely did the 1984 one too. The governor pardoned Vasquez on January 4, 1989. He had served about four years. He is generally counted as the first person in America exonerated because of DNA.
So the same test that put one man in the electric chair let another one walk out of prison, inside of a year, over killings that started a mile apart in Arlington and ended on the Southside of Richmond.
What it left behind
Virginia took the lesson fast. In 1989 it became the first state to build a crime lab that could test DNA, and then the first to keep a DNA database. Every cold case you’ve ever heard solved by a match in a database runs back through that.
The case also ended up in a bestseller. Patricia Cornwell was working as a computer analyst at the state medical examiner’s office in Richmond while it was happening, and her first novel, Postmortem, followed one of the killings closely enough to make a lot of people here angry. She has said she writes about kinds of crimes, not particular ones.
For me the real story is David Vasquez. Everybody remembers this as the case where DNA caught a serial killer. I think about the man who did four years for one of those murders because detectives lied to a guy with an IQ under 70 about his fingerprints until he told them what they wanted to hear.
If Spencer had stopped in 1984, Vasquez probably does all 35 years and nobody ever knows. The science didn’t free him because somebody went back looking for the truth. It freed him almost by accident, because the real killer kept going and left his DNA all over Richmond. That’s the part that sticks with me. Every time somebody tells me a case is closed, I think about the janitor from McDonald’s who confessed to something he didn’t do.
Sources (3)
- Timothy Wilson Spencer, Wikipedia
- The Arlington Serial Killer Who Changed History, Arlington Magazine
- David Vasquez, Innocence Project
More from Richmond
The highway went straight through the Harlem of the South
Richmond built I-95 through the middle of its most famous Black neighborhood, and almost 70 years later the city is still studying how to cover the hole.
There’s still a train inside Church Hill
A hundred years ago a hill in the East End ate a locomotive and at least two men, and nobody has gotten them back out.
From the First Four to the Final Four, and everything after
In 2011 VCU went from a play-in game in Dayton to the Final Four in Houston. Richmond hasn’t been the same city since.
Friends Comments
Displaying 0 comments
No comments yet. Be the first. Thanks for the add!