The billboards that promised you five years
In 1997 Richmond put a threat on the side of a city bus. Murders fell by a third the next year. Whether one caused the other is still an argument.
If you were in Richmond in the late 90s you saw it. Black background, white letters, and a simple message: get caught with an illegal gun and you will do five years in federal prison. It was on fifteen billboards. It was on business cards that cops handed out. It was painted down the entire side of a city bus that ran a different route every day.
I remember the billboards. The one that stuck with me was between Jackson Ward and Northside, going west on the 64/95 interchange. You couldn’t miss it.
The program was called Project Exile and it started in February 1997, the year Richmond had 140 homicides and the worst per-person murder rate in the country.
How it worked
The idea came out of the federal prosecutor’s office in Richmond, working with the police chief and the city’s top local prosecutor. One of the federal prosecutors who built it was James Comey, twenty years before most people learned his name.
Federal sentences for gun crimes were stiffer than Virginia’s. A federal charge meant a minimum of five years with no parole. So every gun case the police made got looked at by a federal agent, and if a federal charge fit, the case went to federal court.
The “exile” part was literal. Federal prisoners do not serve their time down the road. They get shipped wherever there is a bed, which could be several states away.
The case for it
In its first twenty-one months, 372 people were indicted, 440 guns were seized, and the average sentence was a little over four and a half years. Homicides went from 140 in 1997 to 94 in 1998.
It was popular with almost everybody, which never happens with gun policy. The NRA helped pay for the ads. So did local businesses. Other cities copied it within a couple of years.
The case against it
Two economists went back through the numbers in 2003. Their conclusion was that the drop in Richmond was not unusual, because murder was falling fast in cities all over the country at the same time, and that nearly all of the decline would probably have happened without the program.
The other criticism is about who got exiled. Critics, Congressman Bobby Scott among them, argued that the program fell hardest on Black neighborhoods, under sentencing rules that left judges no room, and that it sent people too far away for their families to visit.
Where I land
Hard to say if it worked. Crime got better, but a lot of things went into that.
Murder was falling in cities all over the country at the same time, including plenty that never had a Project Exile. The crack trade that drove so much of the early 90s violence was burning itself out. The late 90s economy was the best in a generation, and a guy with a job has less reason to be standing on a corner. Police departments were hiring with federal money and changing how they worked. Some researchers even point to lead coming out of gasoline and paint a generation earlier.
Pull all of that apart and pin the drop on one billboard campaign? I can’t. Crime got better and Exile was part of the picture. How big a part, nobody really knows.
Sources (4)
- Revisiting Project Exile, VPM News, September 2023
- Project Exile, U.S. Attorney’s Office, Eastern District of Virginia, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
- Prison Sentence Enhancements: The Case of Project Exile, Raphael and Ludwig, 2003
- Look Back: “Murder Capital” No More, Richmond Magazine, January 2020
More from Richmond
The highway went straight through the Harlem of the South
Richmond built I-95 through the middle of its most famous Black neighborhood, and almost 70 years later the city is still studying how to cover the hole.
There’s still a train inside Church Hill
A hundred years ago a hill in the East End ate a locomotive and at least two men, and nobody has gotten them back out.
From the First Four to the Final Four, and everything after
In 2011 VCU went from a play-in game in Dayton to the Final Four in Houston. Richmond hasn’t been the same city since.
Friends Comments
Displaying 0 comments
No comments yet. Be the first. Thanks for the add!