There’s still a train inside Church Hill
A hundred years ago a hill in the East End ate a locomotive and at least two men, and nobody has gotten them back out.
C&O No. 231 is still buried under Church Hill, as far as anybody knows. At least two men whose bodies were never found are down there with it.
I’ve heard Richmond stories that sound a little too good to be true. This one sounds like something somebody’s uncle picked up on a ghost tour. A whole train under the neighborhood. But the train is real.
Trouble from the start
The Church Hill Tunnel was finished in 1873 by the Chesapeake and Ohio. It carried coal east toward Hampton Roads, running about 4,000 feet from near 18th and Marshall in Shockoe Bottom to a ravine near 31st and East Grace.
Digging it was deadly work. The hill’s blue marl is wet clay that shifts, and cave-ins killed men during construction. Within about 30 years, the C&O had a viaduct around the hill and stopped using the tunnel.
It stayed empty for a couple of decades. In the 1920s, the railroad wanted that capacity again. Crews went back underground to widen the tunnel and reinforce it.
October 2, 1925
Roughly 200 men were working inside that afternoon. Engine 231 was bringing ten flat cars into the work zone. It was a 4-4-0 Baldwin built in 1903, with Thomas Mason at the controls and Benjamin F. Mosby working as fireman.
Near the western end, the tunnel collapsed. The state marker puts the section that fell at 190 feet. Dirt and brick crushed the engine’s boiler, releasing scalding steam into the dark.
For most of the 200 men, getting out meant crawling underneath the flat cars, then making their way toward the eastern portal. That exit was most of a mile away.
Mosby escaped the tunnel, but the steam had burned him badly. He died hours later at Grace Hospital. Mason was still in the cab, trapped.
I never heard about any of this growing up. I’m learning it now, researching and writing this story.
Getting to Tom Mason
Crews trying to reach Mason kept bringing more of the hill down. Above them, houses sank and settled. More than a week passed before they reached his body. The Richmonder reports that his coffin had “231” painted on its side.
They never found Richard Lewis or H. Smith, both day laborers. They were most likely Black workers. There isn’t much in the records about either man.
Early reports listed more missing men, then reduced that count to two. But day laborers in 1925 didn’t always make it into the records at all. Four men are known dead. Whether that accounts for everyone is something nobody can promise.
Investigators found that some bracing had been removed or was defective. They never got a clear answer about who was responsible or why.
Sealed up
The C&O decided against spending what it would take to reclaim the tunnel. By 1926, it was filled with sand and sealed at both ends with concrete.
Engine 231 and the ten flat cars stayed where they were. So did Lewis and Smith.
That should have settled it, at least as far as the railroad was concerned.
The 2006 attempt
In the summer of 2006, Gulf & Ohio Railways chairman Pete Claussen started an effort to see whether the engine could be recovered. The Virginia Historical Society agreed to display 231 if it came out.
H.W. Blankenship & Sons, a Midlothian contractor, drilled near 20th and Marshall at Jefferson Park. The plan was to lower a camera into the tunnel.
Neighbors worried the drilling would cause another cave-in. When the bore broke through, water poured from the old plugged portal. Then the city stopped the work. Nobody had pulled permits.
What the camera found was mostly water and muck. “We didn’t see anything,” the contractor told the Times-Dispatch.
A descendant of the engineer wanted the locomotive recovered. Others thought the grave should be left alone. The project went nowhere, and nobody has seriously tried since.
Above the train
Jefferson Park is on top of the collapse. Church Hill rowhouses surround it, and the soil underneath is still soft. George Saunders of the Richmond Railroad Museum told CBS 6 that people talk about reopening the tunnel, but the ground isn’t stable enough.
Downhill, behind renovated warehouses and condos, the western portal is a moss-covered concrete wall. Water seeps from the top. There’s a landscaped patio a few steps away.
The state historical marker at North 18th Street and East Marshall tells you what’s behind that wall. Some of the workers are still inside with the train.
The eastern portal sits in a ravine below East Grace. It’s sealed and overgrown, with a fence keeping people out.
For the 100th anniversary in 2025, the Railroad Museum held a ceremony honoring the four men. Richbrau released a double IPA called Entombed. Richmond made a beer about it. Of course we did.
When I was coming up, Church Hill was crack and heroin blocks, with shootouts in broad daylight. Now it’s gentrified, and that started with the millennial hipsters in the 2010s. Now I see women walking dogs down the street at night with their Stanley cups like it’s nothing. And yes, I’ve done both. I’ve stood at that marker, and I’ve walked Jefferson Park knowing what’s under it.
So should they dig 231 out, or leave Lewis and Smith where they are? Damn, I don’t know. That’s quite the ethical dilemma.
Sources (10)
- Exactly 100 years ago, the Church Hill Train Tunnel collapsed as men worked inside. The true death toll will never be known., The Richmonder, October 2, 2025
- Entombed for a Century: The story of the 1925 Church Hill tunnel collapse, WTVR CBS 6, October 1, 2025
- Starting with the Church Hill tunnel collapse, a filmmaker is uncovering Virginia’s buried history, VPM, September 30, 2021
- Drilling to reach old train begins, Richmond Times-Dispatch (reprinted by BLET), July 13, 2006
- A peek at a buried train, via scientific tunnel vision, Richmond Times-Dispatch (reprinted by BLET), August 9, 2006
- Virginia Town Targets Mystery Train’s Secrets, NPR, June 28, 2006
- Church Hill Tunnel (Marker SA-90), Historical Marker Database, Virginia Department of Historic Resources marker
- The Church Hill Tunnel; Two Portals a World Apart, Abandoned Country, April 22, 2013
- Church Hill Tunnel, Atlas Obscura
- Church Hill Tunnel, Wikipedia
More from Richmond
The highway went straight through the Harlem of the South
Richmond built I-95 through the middle of its most famous Black neighborhood, and almost 70 years later the city is still studying how to cover the hole.
From the First Four to the Final Four, and everything after
In 2011 VCU went from a play-in game in Dayton to the Final Four in Houston. Richmond hasn’t been the same city since.
Bluffington is Richmond
Doug Funnie grew up in Lakeside. Poe, Ellen Glasgow, Lamb of God and a few others put this city in their work too.
Friends Comments
Displaying 0 comments
No comments yet. Be the first. Thanks for the add!