My Ghost Vapes

The cameras on Redd Street are coming down

Richmond and Henrico are dropping the Flock license plate cameras police said helped catch shooters on the same block I wrote about last week. Here’s what they did, what went wrong, and who’s right.

, 5 minute read, by Jake

Last week I wrote about pulling up on Redd Street to volunteer and finding a corner that looked worse than anything I remember from the 2000s. I said the city’s numbers were down, and that the block didn’t feel it.

Here’s something I didn’t know when I wrote that. According to Richmond’s police chief, the cameras on poles around this city helped catch “shooters on Redd Street.” And a Mosby Court arrest. And this week, the city and the county both announced they’re getting rid of them.

What Flock is

Flock Safety sells license plate cameras. They sit on traffic light poles and posts, photograph every car that goes by, read the plate, and log it in a database that police can search. If a plate is on a hot list, a stolen car or a car tied to a shooting, dispatch gets an alert in real time.

Richmond police put up about 100 of them in 2024. The department has spent more than $1 million on Flock since then. Chief Rick Edwards says the cameras go “where our gun-violence hot spots are,” and he won’t say exactly where, because people would tear them down. The locations reporters found were all in the East End and Southside. None west of the Nickel Bridge.

I never noticed them. That’s the point. They’re gray boxes on poles you drive under every day without looking up. But I’ve driven those blocks plenty, and I was on Redd Street a week ago Sunday. My plate is almost certainly sitting in that database right now, logged with a time and a place, and nobody asked me.

Why they’re coming down

Henrico went first. On October 6, county police said they were ending their Flock contract within a week and shutting off 122 cameras. That was less than three months after the county had agreed to renew through 2027.

The reason wasn’t that the cameras didn’t work. It was who else could see the data. Flock runs a national network, and the misuse has been piling up. A Chesterfield police employee was charged with illegally using the system. Henrico found that ten of its own fire marshals had access the law didn’t give them. In Richmond, an ATF agent who had access for another reason ran immigration searches through it, and RPD only found out after the fact. Statewide, a crime commission report this year found agencies keeping data longer than the law allows and sharing it with federal agencies, and nearly a third of the agencies wouldn’t answer.

The Henrico board chair put it this way: officials “cannot ignore the potential for misuse of system data by others.”

Four days later, Mayor Danny Avula said Richmond won’t renew either. His reason was practical. If Henrico’s cameras go dark, a car can leave the city and disappear. “Crime doesn’t stop and start at the city and county line.”

The case for keeping them

Police and a lot of people on their side say this is a mistake.

The chief credits the cameras with arrests in shootings, a killing in Broad Rock and two hit-and-runs. Richmond’s clearance rate went from about 54 percent in 2024 to about 65 percent in 2025. A retired officer told WTVR the answer is tighter safeguards, not turning the system off, and that losing it means “it’s going to take a little longer to get the bad guy occasionally.” The local NAACP chapter said no system is perfect, but families looking for missing people are better off with the cameras up.

The case against

The other side says the cameras were never proven to do much. The homicide clearance rate actually went down over the same stretch, from about 85 percent to about 80. Independent research on plate readers finds a limited effect on solving crime. And a database of everywhere every car has been is exactly the kind of thing that gets used for something nobody voted for. Critics point to immigration tracking and stalking in other states. In Virginia, it has already been misused, by a police employee and by a federal agent.

There’s also the question of where the cameras were. If they’re all in the East End and Southside, then the people being logged every day are the people who live there.

I’m not on the fence about this. Flock cameras are a blatant assault on our Fourth Amendment rights.

The Fourth Amendment says the government can’t search you without a reason and a warrant. A camera that logs every car that passes, guilty or not, and keeps it in a database any officer can search later, is the government searching everybody, all the time, just in case. That’s backwards. You’re supposed to be suspected of something first.

I’ve seen both sides of those blocks. I got barred from every housing project in this city in ’08, and I’ve seen what that corner looks like now. I’m not naive about crime. But no drop in the crime rate can justify violating my rights as a human being. If it did, there’d be no limit to what they could justify next.

Two federal judges, one here in 2024 and one in Norfolk this year, have said these cameras are legal. The people who sued in Norfolk are appealing. I hope they win.

What I take from it

In my perfect world, I’d have enough money to stop working and go to law school, so I could argue constitutional cases for people who can’t afford a lawyer. First Amendment and Fourth Amendment, specifically. Cases like this one.

Because the people on those corners in the East End and Southside are the ones these cameras were pointed at, and they’re the last people who can afford to fight it. Henrico didn’t drop Flock because somebody’s rights got violated. It dropped Flock because the data got loose. Richmond’s dropping it because Henrico did. Nobody in charge has said the thing out loud: watching everybody to catch somebody isn’t policing. It’s surveillance.

The cameras are coming down. Good. Now let’s make sure the next thing they buy doesn’t do the same job with a different name.

Sources (4)

More from Richmond