My Ghost Vapes

The Ship of Theseus is on tour, and it’s from Richmond

GWAR has been a band for over forty years. Nobody who started it is still in it, and last month another of its founders died. Is it the same band?

, 3 minute read, by Jake

There’s an old philosophy problem about a boat.

The Greek hero Theseus sails home, and Athens keeps his ship in the harbor as a monument. Wood rots, so every time a plank goes bad they swap in a new one. A few centuries later there isn’t one original board left in it. Is it still the ship of Theseus?

People have been arguing about that for two thousand years. Richmond has been running the experiment live since 1984.

The band

GWAR started here that year in an abandoned bottling plant called the Richmond Dairy. A punk band called Death Piggy practiced there. Two VCU art students, Hunter Jackson and Chuck Varga, were in the same building making monster costumes for a movie they planned to shoot. The punk band tried on the costumes. The crowd liked the costumes better than the band. The costumes won.

What came out of that is the most Richmond thing this city has ever produced: a metal band of alien barbarians who spray the first ten rows with fake blood. They put out a string of albums in the 90s and got nominated for two Grammys, which is a sentence I enjoy typing. They lost one to Annie Lennox.

For the record, I’ve never seen them. GWAR isn’t really my thing. But you don’t have to like the music to see what it means that this city made it.

The planks

Here’s where the boat comes in. The lineup has turned over again and again. The man at the center of it for thirty years was Dave Brockie, who played the lead singer, Oderus Urungus. He died in his Richmond apartment in March 2014, at 50, of a heroin overdose.

The band didn’t stop. It didn’t recast Oderus either. Michael Bishop, who’d played bass in the band back in the late 80s, came back as a brand new character, Blothar the Berserker, took over the microphone, and sang the very next show. That summer at GWAR-B-Q, the band gave Oderus a Viking funeral.

Then last month, Chuck Varga died of cancer. He was 68. He was one of the two art students in the dairy, and he played the Sexecutioner on stage for 37 years.

Today there’s nobody in GWAR who was there in 1984. The longest-serving members joined in 1988 and 1989. The newest one joined two years ago. And they’re still putting out records.

So is it GWAR?

One answer says no. A band is its people, and when the people are gone you’re watching a tribute act with the rights to the name.

The other answer says a band was never the people in the first place. It’s a set of songs, a way of doing things, and a relationship with a crowd. Swap every plank and the boat still floats and still goes where it always went.

GWAR is the cleanest test case there is, because it was built to be replaceable. The characters are the band. The humans inside were always, on purpose, behind a mask.

A later philosopher, Thomas Hobbes, added a twist. Suppose somebody saved all the old rotten planks and nailed them back together. Now there are two ships. Which one is real? Plenty of bands have run that experiment too, with two versions touring at once and lawyers in the middle.

Me? I don’t care who’s under the mask. If it looks like GWAR, sounds like GWAR and soaks the front row like GWAR, it’s GWAR. That’s what the masks were for.

Sources (4)